Browsing by Author "Nikoo, Shoghi W"
Now showing 1 - 1 of 1
Results Per Page
Sort Options
- ItemOpen AccessDecision-making in Practice: Surgical Actionability and Consent in Pelvic Floor Medicine(2014-05-27) Nikoo, Shoghi W; Ducey, ArielIn this thesis I explore how patients’ problems are made surgically actionable so that decisions regarding and consent to surgery may be produced. I employ ethnographic observations of the material and semiotic practices in which surgeons and patients are engaged. Surgical actionability arises in a cascade of practices that produce diseases such that they meet conditions of actionability. Disagreement between realities of a problem, or uncertainty regarding surgical outcomes, may produce disruptive turbulence in these cascades. Surgeons manage turbulence by shifting sites of decision onto ‘patient choice’ – if a patient decides she is bothered enough to justify the risks, surgery may go forward. However, patients’ decisions rarely take on this ‘rational’ character; instead, they appear to be non-formal and centre on issues other than risks and benefits. I question the value of ‘respect for autonomy’ and propose that policy based in care, with a focus on the particularities of disease and decision production, may serve patients better.