The Integration of Community Service Learning and Reflection in a Post-Secondary Chemistry Lab
Date
2023-06
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Abstract
This manuscript-based dissertation was prompted by first and second-year university students' challenges in learning chemistry due to the traditional focus of chemistry labs on recalling information rather than applying critical thinking. The three manuscripts (Chapters 2 to 4) in this dissertation explore the possibility of supporting students’ meaningful learning through the integration of Community Service Learning (CSL) and Reflection in the Analytical Chemistry II lab. This multi-year project analyzes three different cohorts of students. Chapter 2 (Manuscript 1) focuses on the CSL design intervention and students’ attitudes toward the service learning activity. Post-instructional surveys were completed, and the data was analyzed using a mixed methodological approach. All learners self-reported favourable engagement, attitudes, and higher self-confidence after the CSL activity. Chapter 3 (Manuscript 2) builds on the previous chapter by exploring how intentional reflection enhances students’ conscious awareness of their learning. A series of reflective essays were assigned at the beginning, during, and after the CSL activity. Reflective essays, focus group interviews, and student observations were collected from fourteen students using a case study methodology. Students articulated their learning progression across three phases: (a) connection with and contribution to the world, (b) identification of areas that are missing and development of reasoning abilities, and (c) integration in learning. Students reported liking the reflective essays because they enhanced their abilities to develop self-competency in learning. Chapter 4 (Manuscript 3) further extends this research by exploring students' attitudes toward a range of different reflective strategies. Content analysis was selected as both methodology and method to analyze the data from reflective writings, reflective discussions, and scrapbook reflections. The combination of reflective exercises supported students in recognizing the interconnections between the ideas they were learning. In addition, the step-by-step process of teaching reflection increased students’ comfort level and willingness to learn Chemistry. Chapter 5 concludes that the integration of CSL and Reflection can serve an important role in students’ academic enhancement, personal growth, and civic engagement while supporting practical skills and intellectual stimulation in the laboratory.
Description
Keywords
reflection, community service learning, teaching and learning, laboratory, chemistry education
Citation
Ho, K. (2023). The integration of community service learning and reflection in a post-secondary chemistry lab (Doctoral thesis, University of Calgary, Calgary, Canada). Retrieved from https://prism.ucalgary.ca.